December 2014
Dear Santa,
I like aliens but my sister told me aliens aren’t real. Can you prove aliens are real?
Merry Christmas.
-Tally
P.S. I also want a sonic screwdriver. I think it will help when my dad tries to fix things but can’t.
December 2024
This is not how the bathroom normally looks. For starters, it’s usually much smaller. And emptier.
“Hey, Mom and Dad made hot choc—woah. This is not the bathroom.”
I didn’t have time to give Maya a “no shit” look before a huge beast clomped past us on its way to the bar that had replaced the sinks and counter. It walked on two hairy and hooved legs, standing at least seven feet tall. Its arms were basically the same as its legs, its entire body was covered in thick brown and white fur, and atop its horse-shaped face were two thick antlers. Because of its posture, it took me a while to realize that it was a reindeer.
By the time my brain had made the connection, the reindeer was sitting on a bar stool and talking to the creature pouring drinks. This creature was decidedly not a reindeer. It was scaly and small and humanoid, its eyes like vertical slits, its ears pointy. An… elf? Were elves reptilian? I couldn’t remember any mention of scales in any story of elves.
The reindeer and elf exchanged a few words after which the elf poured an amber liquid into a glass and slid it over to the reindeer, who picked it up with both hooves and downed the whole thing.
My older sister grabbed my arm. “Um, Tally, that reindeer just slammed a bourbon neat.”
I rolled my eyes. Ever since she went to Ireland for a summer, she was always pretending she knew more about alcohol than I did. She could’ve just said whiskey.
“Hey, Jingles, is the Milky Way Skyline open again?” the reindeer said in English.
The elf shrugged, its eyes blinking sideways like a lizard instead of up and down. “I hope not. Why?”
“You got a few visitors.” The reindeer nodded its antlers toward us, and my sister stepped slightly behind me.
When the elf—Jingles—looked over at us, I dumbly raised my hand and waved. Jingles looked less than thrilled to see us. In fact, Jingles let out a big sigh. “Santacles is back to his old tricks, I see. It would be nice if he opened the portal somewhere else.”
“There’s only so many places you can put a knot in spacetime,” the reindeer pointed out.
Jingles crunched their tiny claws into a fist. “Well, I’m not dealing with them. Humans can never keep their cool.”
“Excuse me, kids,” a voice boomed from behind us.
Maya jumped and made a small noise. A creature as big as the reindeer had stepped out from our bathroom door. It was emanating coldness, rendering our Christmas jammies utterly useless—even Maya’s matching old-fashioned flannel set. The sight of my sister, at a bar, wearing an outfit full of skiing penguins almost made me laugh. Then I realized that my own wasn’t much better. My pants were adorned with reindeer in various poses, tangled up in Christmas lights. I hoped the reindeer at the bar didn’t look too closely.
The cold creature behind us was basically a sentient white blob with a pointy nose, black mouth, and black eyes. It also wore a red scarf, though it was unclear whether it was wearing the scarf or if the scarf was part of its body. Despite its size and dark eyes, the creature was smiling kindly down at us, waiting for us to move out of the way. I tugged my sister off to the side and the creature blobbed toward the bar.
“Fr. Ostie!” the reindeer greeted. “Happy Holly Days!”
“Happy Holly Days!” Fr. Ostie returned, taking the drink Jingles had already made for him—a steaming hot drink at odds with the big blob’s cold atmosphere. “Looks like you got a fan over there, Dashaway.” Out of the blobby mass formed an appendage that again pointed in our direction.
The reindeer peered at me and then waved us over. I immediately followed orders, but Maya held me back. “Wait, you’re seriously going over there?”
“Duh.” I wasn’t going to miss the chance to talk to… whatever these things were. “What else are we supposed to do? Stand in the corner and stare?”
“Yes,” Maya said. “That’s exactly what we should do.”
Extricating my arm from her viselike grip, I shook my head. “Staring is rude.” Then I put on what I hoped was a friendly smile and trotted over to the trio of nightmarish Christmas characters. When the reindeer got a better view of my outfit, he let out a roar that I interpreted hopefully as a laugh.
“I didn’t realize my tumble with the Garcías’ twinkle lights had reached all of Earth,” the reindeer said.
“Hey, kid, what’s a Gunsen Rose?” Fr. Ostie asked.
“I don’t know,” I said hesitantly.
“I think it’s a type of rock,” the reindeer answered. “It’s usually like a squarish or round shape. I’ve seen ’em when the big guy takes us over to Earth.”
“It’s a band,” my sister answered, startling me. I hadn’t realized she followed me over to the bar. This declaration didn’t seem to explain things more for the creatures, who stared blankly at her. “A classic rock band.” She pointed to my torso, and I realized I was wearing a Guns n’ Roses T-shirt.
“How did you two get here?” Jingles asked in their grating voice, unamused by the gaiety their friends were sharing with us.
“We walked through the bathroom door,” I explained. “Where exactly are we?”
“This is the Biegan-Polnoznee,” Jingles squeaked. “Home to the best bar in the North Galaxy.”
“You’re aliens?” I said. Goosebumps formed on my skin. I remembered when I was little and obsessed with aliens—E.T., Alf, Doctor Who, Star Wars, Star Trek, the works. Anything to do with extraterrestrials had my attention. Which my dad loved—he was a cosmologist—and my mom endured—she found the idea of aliens intensely disconcerting. In her role as older sister, Maya had taken it upon herself to declare aliens weren’t real and that any conversations discussing them were moot. We were a divided household. On this topic, at least.
“Well, he can’t be an alien. We have reindeer on Earth,” she added, gesturing to the bipedal reindeer.
The reindeer roared out another laugh. “Oh, I’m not a reindeer.”
Maya’s elbow jabbed into my side, and she whispered in my ear, “Clearly we’re having some sort of shared hallucination. That eggnog tasted weird earlier. Not like grandma’s at all.”
“All eggnog tastes weird if you haven’t had the real stuff,” the not-reindeer said, unabashedly revealing he’d been listening in. “Jingles, get the two humans some eggnog on me.”
Jingles begrudgingly nodded and hopped down off the stool they’d been standing on to climb a ladder to a high shelf behind the bar.
“So are all Christmas stories based on aliens?” I asked, climbing onto one of the tall stools next to the reindeer. Fr. Ostie was a little too cold for me to sit next to without a jacket. “Is Santa an alien?”
Before either alien could answer, Jingles was back, slamming down two clear glasses of a chai latte-colored drink with brown powder on top. Curiosity getting the better of her, Maya clambered awkwardly onto the stool next to me. We each took a sip of Real Eggnog and shared a glance. It tasted nothing like my grandma’s eggnog, and especially not like the almond-based stuff my mom had us drinking this year. This was thick and sweet and spiced with something I couldn’t quite put my finger on. It was like the warmest spice ever invented, heating me up from the inside even though the drink itself was cold.
“I don’t think it’s all non-humans,” Fr. Ostie said, answering my question. “Jack Frost was a man.”
My sister snorted, wiping off her eggnog mustache. “Sure.”
Well, well, well, I thought, Look who’s on board with aliens now.
“And the yeti is just fake,” the not-reindeer added. “Though I don’t know if that’s specifically a Holly Days thing.”
“Are you trying to say ‘holidays’?” Maya asked. She seemed to have just decided to ignore the fact that we were talking to LITERAL ALIENS and fell back into her habit of correcting people so they knew she was the smartest one in the room. Though, when I thought about it, she’d been grumpy this whole Christmas. It was our first without our grandma, who usually made cookies and her own eggnog.
The not-reindeer shook his big head, nearly whacking me with an antler. I ducked just in time. “Is that what humans are calling it these days? No, we don’t do Christmas or Hanukkah in the North Galaxy. We celebrate the Holly Days, when the Holly comes into view.”
“Dashaway, they don’t know what the Holly is,” Fr. Ostie said, slapping his friend’s furry back with a blob arm.
When I looked at my sister, she giggled a little and pointed to her upper lip. I reached up to feel my own eggnog mustache and grinned, wiping it off with the back of my hand.
“Everyone knows the Holly!” Jingles squeaked, scratching behind their pointed ear. “Stupid humans.”
“Oh, come on, Jingles. Go get these kids some more eggnog as an apology,” the not-reindeer, Dashaway, countered. Jingles grumbled under their breath but hopped back down off the stool, presumably only because Dashaway was going to pay again.
Both Maya and I had already chugged our Real Eggnog and were not about to decline another glass of warmth. Even if it was coming from a grouchy alien elf.
With said grouch out of the way, Dashaway and Fr. Ostie explained the North Galaxy’s version of Christmas.
Every “galactic era” in the North Galaxy—which corresponded to about a year on Earth—a strange pulsating light appeared in the sky that no alien scientist had been able to explain. It seemed to wink in and out of existence with strange regularity and seemed to have no mass despite the heat radiating from it. The light was reddish and roundish with a few leaf-shaped flares that were different every galactic month. Apparently, holly plants existed in the North Galaxy, too, and so the strange light was called the Holly and became a beacon of togetherness. Everyone would gather on Biegan-Polnoznee, where the Holly was most visible, to marvel at the unknown and appreciate the things the universe had to offer.
“But I still don’t understand how the Holly Days spread to Earth. Or got attached to Christianity,” Maya said, eagerly watching Jingles sprinkle that mysterious brown spice on top of the new glasses of eggnog. The only food Maya got this excited about were my grandma’s chocolate chip cookies.
“You can thank Santacles for that.” Jingles set our second round of drinks down more gently but their tone was still tortured. “He just loooves using the portal to go to Earth. I hope he gets here soon to deal with you.”
I was too excited to be hurt by Jingles’ obvious disdain for us. Actual fucking aliens were chatting with me, giving me space drinks—who cared if they liked me or not? At least they weren’t trying to kill us or anything. So I smiled at Jingles and said, “Thanks for the eggnog. It’s even better than a portal that brings us Christmas.”
Jingles rolled their eyes but allowed a small, pleased smile to break through their scowl. “It’s my sibling’s recipe.” They paused and added, “The eggnog and the portal.”
Still thinking of Grandma and her cookies, I dipped a finger into the eggnog and stuck it into my mouth just to get a taste. A tingly warmth spread through my chest. “It must be hard to celebrate the Holly Days without your sibling.” This Christmas had been less than jolly for us, too, and even though I tried to just ignore it, seeing my sister smile and engage in the conversation for the first time this whole Christmas season made it clear that she was hurting just like Jingles was.
Dashaway cut in to say, “Nickles was one of the good ones. Put the portal in this bar so anyone could stop by for Jingles’ fare.”
“Nickles and Santacles were thick as thieves,” Fr. Ostie added.
“What happened to them?” I was surprised that my sister asked this. She usually stayed away from any topic that might make someone uncomfortable. Unless, of course, the discomfort came from being wrong; Maya loved being the one in the know. Especially after being the first in the family to go to college.
Fr. Ostie and Dashaway exchanged an uncomfortable glance, but it was Jingles who answered us. “Portals aren’t always stable. Nickles created one on Ostie’s planet that went to a galaxy nearby yours. Hasn’t been back since.” Jingles pointed to a shelf so high above the bottles of liquid that even Dashaway had to look up. The shelf was full of what looked like different rocks and gems. “Nickles always brought back a sample from their travels.”
Jingles’ stoicism almost distracted me from the two main things they’d just said: 1) Their sibling was basically an alien Indiana Jones, and 2) all of these portals seemed to open fairly close to humanity. Of course, I wasn’t sure what they considered “near.” Probably light-years away at least. If only I’d paid more attention in my physics class; maybe I could have been hailed as a genius for discovering something new about space.
Next to me, my sister’s eggnog was already almost gone again, whereas I’d been too distracted to take more than a sip or two. Maya’s cheeks were rosy and her eyes glittering. Even though I didn’t want to share, I slid my cup over to my sister to let her have the rest of mine. She never really enjoyed things without restraint anymore. Even something as simple as an eggnog drink. Well, it wasn’t so simple when I factored in the context surrounding the eggnog, but still, it was just a drink. And Maya was fully enjoying it.
All of a sudden, as if to burst the bubble of the somber moment, the bathroom door—or, I supposed, the portal—slammed open to reveal another gigantic, furry beast. Different from the not-reindeer, this beast was mostly covered in red fur with hands like white mittens, feet like leather boots, and a nose as luminescent as I imagined Rudolph’s to be. “Ho ho ho ho ho!” the creature boomed, and all three aliens—even Jingles—perked up at the sight of this guy.
“Santacles!” all three shouted as the creature clomped over.
Santacles looked… not how I’d expected. I’d expected him to have tentacles, because of his name, or to be mostly humanoid. Not this red-and-white sasquatch with a lightbulb nose. But he was smiling and jolly and had a big belly, just like the Santa Claus I was familiar with. He ordered a plate of cookies and an eggnog for himself before looking directly down at me, his eyes like warm chestnuts. “It seems I owe you an apology, Tally,” Santacles said, holding out a piece of worn notebook paper.
Mouth agape, I took the paper from him and studied the writing. It was a letter I’d written to Santa Claus ten years ago. More accurately, it was a letter I’d dictated to my grandma to write to Santa for me. Ten years ago, I’d asked for aliens to be real. And they were.
Maya read over my shoulder, eyes full of not-just-sadness. Anytime something reminded her of Grandma, she would usually cry—or try not to cry. But faced with my grandma’s distinct handwriting, she was smiling as if remembering how much Grandma used to love writing our Santa letters for us. Instead of just focusing on how Grandma wasn’t here anymore.
“It took me a decade, but I hope it was worth it,” Santacles said to me, gesturing around at the bar.
Jingles huffed and stood up on their stool. “Don’t use my bar for your gift giving act!”
Instead of getting mad, Santacles laughed in ho’s again and shook his head. “Oh, come on, Jingles. You won’t be so upset when you see my Christmas gift for you!”
Jingles crossed their scaly arms, long nose pointed in the air. “I don’t need a Christmas gift. Escort these humans home.”
“You’ll like this one. Even though it’s ten years too late, too.” Santacles winked at my sister and I before reopening the portal door. In came another scaly, elf-like creature, almost identical to Jingles but taller and more purplish in color.
“Nickles!” Jingles launched themself over the counter and into their sibling’s arms. Nickles had the same voice as Jingles—high-pitched and reedy—but their tone was more like Santacles’s. Fr. Ostie and Dashaway joined in the reunion. Something with Santacles’s magic or alien powers seemed to be making everyone feel warm and fuzzy. Or maybe it was the eggnog and the Holly.
Santacles smiled at the sibling-and-friend reunion before turning to Maya and me. “I’m sorry you had to wait so long for your Christmas wish. Ten Earth years ago, when Nickles got stuck in the portal that we thought led to the Andromeda Galaxy, it was because I’d granted his Christmas wish—a new portal. So I stopped granting wishes that were too multidimensional.”
“Do a lot of people ask for ‘multidimensional’ gifts?” I asked.
Santacles nodded. “You’ll be surprised to know that most gifts actually come from parents or families; I only have to be around for the big ones.” He leaned forward. “But when Nickles popped back into existence on my sleigh-ship with a story for the ages, I knew I needed to make things right.”
“But why did Maya have to come along? It’s been so inconvenient for her,” I asked Santacles.
Maya’s cheeks got even redder; she wouldn’t look me in the eye even as Santacles handed her a similar piece of notebook paper with her own handwriting on it. She didn’t even read it before handing it over to me. She’d been old enough to write her own Christmas letter ten years ago.
As my eyes scanned the words, I burst into laughter, and soon, my sister joined me, for once not embarrassed to have been proven wrong. About eggnog and aliens.
Maya and I enjoyed the rest of our Christmas Eve night with Santacles and the other Christmas aliens, learning about other extraterrestrial origins of holiday stories, as well as Nickles’ travels to the Andromeda Galaxy. Nickles had brought back a dark, coal-like rock back with them that left charcoal streaks on our hands after we held it.
Maya and I drank our weight in Real Eggnog, both enjoying our Christmas wishes coming true. Even though it was ten years later than asked for, it felt right that it was Grandma’s letters that brought back the Christmas spirit.
December 2014
Dear Santa Claus,
I really love Grandma’s cookies. We leave them out and you eat them every year, so I’m pretty sure you do, too. But she can’t really ever get eggnog right. What I want this year is the recipe for my grandma’s cookies so I can make them myself now that I know how to cook, and the best cup of eggnog ever. I don’t understand the hype, and I always feel bad when Grandma pours me some and I don’t drink it all.
Thanks and Merry Christmas,
-Maya
P.S. I think Tally wants to see aliens for Christmas. I don’t think they exist, but if they really are real, that would be cool. I’d like to see that, too. But don’t tell Tally.
-Ryn PB
Author’s Note: I hope you enjoyed this odd, alien Christmas tale that started as a note on my Notes App, as many of my stories do, which only read “Christmas on another planet” and got mixed with the astrophysics book I was reading as well as the inevitable sadness that comes from missing a relative you want to be with you during the holidays. So this story is for Grandma Ronnie, whose game “The Farfanoogles” I’ve also considered making into a story.